Gaining and Losing Face in China
Rain was pelting down, angry rivulets screaming down the windscreen. I sighed, nervously, as heavy rains would inevitably delay my flight. The taxi had been punctual, organised by one of only a handful of people in China I could really trust. Still, I had not been entirely honest with her either, only divulging I was taking a trip to Hong Kong, omitting that it would be a one-way flight. No return. It was better if she was not implicated. Questions would be asked, and at least this way, she could reply with honesty. She was not to know until later, and even then I would not tell her my actual destination.
It was so strange leaving China. You are meant to feel emotional, engulfed by a certain sadness, clinging on to make these final lasting memories. But there was nothing, just emptiness and overwhelming numbness. The relief I had been expecting had not materialised, not then anyway. And there was no regret in saying goodbye to friends; those that mattered I would see again in the different countries we call ‘home’. In this shrunken world we live in, everyone is only a few flights away, and Skype or Face-time connect us in the meantime. China is just a phase, a rite of passage for the band of English-as-foreign-language teachers. One home in a string of many, but never intended to become permanent. My departure from China was just the end of one chapter, and not the best one. Not one I felt the need to reread.. Not then anyway, maybe later when the dust had settled and I could look back and add it the list of ‘experiences’.
At the airport I tried to subdue my anxiety. Not about flying, I am pretty much a pro by now. But my exit from China did not happen as planned and I would not be able to relax until the plane was in the air and I had left Chinese soil and airspace. And although I had nothing to reproach myself about, a door had been closed, possibly forever. I had spent my last few days and hours carefully dodging my agent, arranging a visa for Vietnam, whilst hastily disposing of my meagre belongings. Within the small local community of expats an oven, a portable induction cooker and even a handy airing rack were prized possessions and my ex-colleagues descended on my flat like vultures on a corpse, picking over the scraps.
My return to China in March 2017 had been fraught with problems. My agent’s incompetence had not only prevented my timely arrival back in Hangzhou, it further marred the next few weeks as he seemed clueless about how to secure my residence permit. A simple procedure that takes just a couple of days if you know what to do. Instead of gathering the forms and papers himself, he eventually offloaded the task onto the school I was working for… In good Chinese fashion, he was happy to take the money and let others do the work… To add insult to injury, my agent had also negotiated a separate deal with the school to increase the fee paid to him because I was a properly qualified teacher… Not that any of the additional money ever saw my pocket… All in all, just like I was not exactly in awe of my agent’s performance, the school were equally unimpressed with him. He was already skating on thin ice as he had previously introduced a string of totally unsuitable teachers, so the school were keen to cut ties with him at the end of the school year. However, as my contract was with the agent and not the school, as often is the case in China, this meant I would not be able to continue teaching at that school.
Of course, I was not privy to the conversation that took place between the school’s principal and my agent and I can only surmise what happened from the snippets that reached me, and from my Chinese friend’s interpretation… ‘You have done nothing wrong,’ she translated the events, ‘They just want to get rid of the agent, and are using any excuse to justify this…’ Apparently, I failed at team work… a flippant remark made by the 24-year old British ‘academic manager’ of the school, who was catapulted into the Chinese labour force straight from uni, ready to teach English, with not a clue about real teaching nor about a Western style workplace where discussion and exchange of ideas are welcomed… Not so in China!! Having arrived at the school in the middle of the school year, it only seemed normal to me that any professional teacher would ask questions about the how and what of the curriculum and teaching methods, if only to ensure continuity for the students. Not so in China!!! Questions are taboo; it was not a wise move on my part…
‘Michael (my agent) refused to accept what we were saying,’ one person in the know at school confided. ‘Well, schools can only employ teachers directly after they have completed a full year with their agent,’ Michael stubbornly insisted. Maybe the school indeed wanted to employ me directly in September, but refused to pay Michael’s price for buying me out… And there will have been a price, I can assure you, a hefty one… I still had another seven months left on my contract with him. Throughout August employment offers from the school, in various guises, blipped up on my WeChat. Maybe I would be interested to be the school’s substitute teacher, filling in when other teachers were not available… Or how about just coming back for one month in September and then they would rekindle the negotiations with my agent to release me from my contract…? But without a real guarantee of a secure job and freedom from the agent, I would have been foolish to oblige. At the end of the day, the school were equally culpable and never substantiated my ‘shortcomings’, as honesty would have meant someone would ‘lose face’ and that would never happen… I was the fall guy, no chance of clearing my name.
In his infinite wisdom, Michael forgot to inform me of the bad tidings (his ‘company’ losing the contract with the school) until a full three weeks later, the end of July . And instead of being proactive in securing me an alternative job before schools closed for the holidays, he waited and waited in the expectation that I would be able to persuade my school to change their mind… Once back from my trip to Japan, it took me a mere two days to have two firm job offers in hand: one in China and one in Vietnam… The Chinese one was by far the more lucrative, but in the end I had no option but the turn it down. No way was I prepared to pay Michael US$ 3000 to buy my way out of my contract when the only reason I could not return to the school was down to his conduct, and not mine… Believe me, I tried. I was willing to pay him US$1000 – I would have earned it back within the first month, but the $3000 he insisted on??? ‘You don’t owe him anything,’ my Chinese friend (who is in the business of placing English teachers with schools) assured me. ‘He breached the contract, not you.. He lost the contract with the school, and that puts him in breach..’ I had read the small print in the contract before signing, but never in a million years had I thought that a breach clause, or series of clauses, would ever apply to me…
I accepted the position in Vietnam, delaying my arrival until September to first make full use of the summer break and enjoy my planned trip to Malaysia. And so I set in motion the train of deception as I could not afford for anyone in China to become suspicious… I took days to reply to my agent’s messages and postponed meetings until the end of the summer vacation under the pretence that as I was too busy; it was my holiday after all. I point blank refused to put myself through a series of unpaid demo lessons when I had already two job offers in the bag, just on the basis of an interview… And I certainly would not entertain the idea of jobs outside of Hangzhou…
I finally left China at the end of August. Ultimately, it was easier for me to just pack my bags and quietly leave the country, not to return. I know I could have fought it, and involved a lawyer… As I found out in August, many clauses in my contract did not comply with Chinese labour law, making it a worthless piece of paper and invalid in a court. My agent had breached the contract long before I did, as he did not pay me for the days I worked in July… but by then I had had it with China and the lies for the sake of ‘saving face’.. I firmly closed the door of my apartment one last time, leaving the key in a secure place for the agent. I would wait until I had reached Hong Kong before sending him a message; I did not want to be in China when he unleashed his fury.
Would the agent really have had the power to prevent me leaving China? He certainly could not make good on his threat of cancelling my residence permit: he did not have my passport. Would Chinese immigration officers really have detained me at the airport until I paid up the US$3000?? Would the agent really have added me to the blacklist so I can never again obtain a work visa for China, or maybe not even enter China on a tourist visa?? The rumour mill is rife with scaremongering and speculation and I really did not have the stomach for the legal wrangling that would have ensued. Tired of arguing what seemed like a lost cause, I did not want to wait to find out. It was time to leave the Chinese adventure behind, it had run its course and I was thoroughly unimpressed…
Sitting in the lounge at Hong Kong airport, safe from the threats of my agents and the tentacles of Chinese authority, I dispatched my messages and waited to board my onward flight. But just as the morning downpour in Hangzhou had thwarted a speedy exit from the country, an impending typhoon affected flights in Hong Kong. An aborted landing attempt on arrival and a three hour delay for take-off later, I was finally on my way to Hanoi.
Vietnam, a new country, a new chapter…



Like this:
Like Loading...